Wednesday, November 12, 2014

Jerusalem: The First and Last Battleground!

Dear Friend,

Rami Khouri is a trusted (Christian) observer residing in Beirut, Lebanon. Here is his assessment of what is really happening right now on the ground, as tensions mount throughout I/P and especially in Jerusalem.

Let me preface his comments by thanking our son-in-law Jim and the Lake Michigan Presbytery for granting me a private audience with Fr. George Makhlouf, an Antiochian Orthodox priest, now living in retirement with his son in Atlanta, Georgia. (He spoke at various venues throughout the Presbytery over the last few weeks).

The most striking memory of my visit with him (last Saturday) was his recollection, as a five-year old boy, of an announcement over the PA system where he and his family were living in W. Jerusalem (yes, W. not E): "Unless you leave [your homes], you will share the fate of the residents of Yeir Dassin". (This was in 1948. He was born in 1943)

Background: The Hagganah (predecessors of the Israeli Defense Forces - IDF) massacred 250 of the villagers in that community, terrorizing Arab Palestinians so that, in fear for their lives, they fled and became refugees. Over 450 villages were destroyed!

Of course, Fr. George's family fled.

With that as a personal reference, please read Rami Khouri's commentary on the situation on the ground as we speak. One last caveat: I strongly dislike Rami's conclusion, as though there is NO hope for a different outcome than MAD - Mutual Assured Destruction. Our better natures, our "second nature" insists there is a better, nonviolent way. We need to be about planting seeds that will grow to fruition to bring about a joint harvesting of liberty and justice for all. JRK

Rami G. Khouri| The Daily Star (Jerusalem as the Last Battle) (Nov. 12, 2014 edition)

The escalating isolated incidents of violence between Israelis and Palestinians during the past few months have focused heavily on Jerusalem, and for good reason. The reason is not only the religious significance of the Noble Sanctuary/Temple Mount area that is holy to both people; it is that Jerusalem today is a microcosm of the whole Zionism-Arabism conflict, and a replay of the nationalist contestation that Zionism won in the period from the 1930s to 1948.

Jerusalem today is more than a major symbol of identity and sovereignty for Israelis and Palestinians. It is the place where all the key elements of conflict, identity and national rights converge and where the two battling communities are most closely intertwined with one another, thus heightening the sense of vulnerability that defines both sides.

Clashes between Israeli troops and Palestinian demonstrators have occurred virtually daily in the past few months, and reached a peak in the past week after Israeli troops stormed the Al-Aqsa Mosque last Wednesday. On Monday, Palestinians killed an Israeli soldier and a woman and wounded two others in stabbing incidents in Tel Aviv and the occupied West Bank. Jerusalem is the emotional focal point of the Palestinian attacks against Israelis, but such incidents have occurred across Palestine, including Jerusalem, the West Bank Israeli settlement of Alon Shvut and Tel Aviv.

Jerusalem today for Palestinians is about the battle between Israel’s attempts to Judaize the city after formally “annexing” it (which virtually the whole world does not recognize) and the Palestinian insistence on resisting the Zionist efforts to control and own the land of mandated Palestine. This battle has been taking place for nearly a century now. Israeli settlers have been trying for years to move into Arab areas of Jerusalem, like Silwan and Sheikh Jarrah, either by buying homes surreptitiously or forcibly by inhabiting real estate that Israel declares to be state-owned. Because the Palestinian Authority and the Palestine Liberation Organization (the two overlapping but moribund leadership agencies for Palestinians) are not present in Jerusalem, the Arab residents of the city are on their own in defending their homes and lands.

The absence of forces under the control of President Mahmoud Abbas also means that the PA cannot quell Palestinian demonstrations against Israel, as happens in all other parts of the West Bank, where PA forces more often than not act to defend Israel as much as to keep peace among Palestinians, unfortunately. Arab Jerusalemites are essentially ungoverned and unrepresented politically, because they do not fall under Palestinian authority and they are under-served by an Israeli state that also keeps building new settlements on lands surrounding the holy city. Because of this condition of living in a political vacuum, Palestinians in Jerusalem have only themselves to rely on to defend their lands and rights, and in cases of extreme threats and violence used against them, they resort to violence such as we are witnessing these days.

The intense symbolism of Jerusalem for Palestinians includes two dimensions: the holy sites of the Noble Sanctuary, especially the Dome of the Rock and Al-Aqsa Mosque, but also the city as the capital of Palestine, even though a Palestinian state does not exist yet. If Jerusalem is allowed to fall to Zionist colonialism and become fully Judaized, the entire Palestinian national cause would have been dealt a fatal blow. Jerusalem has always been a central battle in the Arab war with Zionism – but for many Palestinians it is now also the last battle.

Typically, Israeli leaders misinterpret the reasons why Palestinians defend themselves by attacking Israelis who are eating up the remaining Arab parts of Jerusalem. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told parliament after the attacks against Israelis in Tel Aviv that, “Terror ... is being directed at all parts of the country for a simple reason: The terrorists, the inciters, want to drive us from everywhere. As far as they are concerned, we should not be in Jerusalem, Tel Aviv or anywhere.”

This brazen lie by Israel’s top leader reflects a widespread sentiment among Israelis and some Western Jews that Palestinians are violent anti-Semites who want to drive all Jews out of Israel and Palestine, and that the Palestinian leadership under Abbas incites ordinary Palestinians to attack and kill Israelis. This is a bizarre thing for Israelis to say, after they have been directly negotiating with Abbas and Yasser Arafat before him for 20 years now, to achieve a two-state solution that sees Israeli and Palestinian states living peacefully side by side.

The historic struggle for the land of Palestine has now symbolically boiled down to Israeli settlers and soldiers with guns, and Palestinian young men with knives, stones and cars, trying to kill, dominate or expel the other.

Rami G. Khouri is published twice weekly in THE DAILY STAR and can be followed on Twitter @ramikhouri.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Daily Star on November 12, 2014, on page 7.

Read more:

Follow us: @DailyStarLeb on Twitter | DailyStarLeb on Facebook

There is no PEACE without JUSTICE; there is no justice without LOVE.